How Creative Affects Meta Ads Performance: Professional Photo or Authentic UGC Video?
User behavior on social media is changing fast. What worked not long ago often isn’t enough today. Instagram and Facebook are pushing short, authentic videos that people respond to far more naturally. So we decided to put the trend to the test and, for one of our clients, tested two different creatives: a professional banner vs. UGC Reels. How did it turn out?

In this article
User behavior on social media is changing fast. What worked not long ago (like perfectly lit product photos) often isn’t enough today. Instagram and Facebook are pushing short, authentic videos that people respond to far more naturally. So we decided to put the trend to the test and, for one of our clients, tested two different creatives: a professional banner vs. UGC Reels. How did it turn out?
Why should you care?
Maybe you, too, rely on beautiful product photos and see video as more of an add-on. But users today behave differently:
- they place more trust in authentic content
- they respond better to natural Reels than to “ad visuals”
- UGC comes across as a recommendation, not an ad
So the hypothesis was: “A UGC video will bring more purchases and better ROAS than a static photo.”
How the test worked
To get relevant data, both ad sets had:
- the same budget
- the same copy and CTA
- the same landing page
- the same campaign structure
Just one thing was different: the creative format – UGC video vs. static photo.

Results: the UGC video beat the banners on every key metric
Interpreting the results
- The authentic video brought in more customers at a lower cost.
- ROAS was significantly higher.
- People responded better to the video (CTR +85%).
- The static photo brought in customers with a higher order value.
Why does UGC work better?
- It feels natural and authentic.
- It blends into the feed among regular content.
- It shows the product in context, which builds trust.
- It generates higher engagement, which directly affects campaign performance.
What to take away for your campaigns
1. Today, authenticity sells better than perfection
People want to see the real product in action.
2. Engagement leads to purchases
Reels naturally generate more interactions, and therefore more sales.
3. Optimization TIP: static banners still have their place
They could come in handy where a higher average order value is the goal.
Next steps: how can you put results like these to work in your campaigns right away?
1. Increase investment in the winning creative
If you want better ROAS and lower CPA, deliberately put more budget behind UGC videos.
2. Prepare more video variants
One video isn’t enough. We recommend at least 2–3 additional UGC variants so the ad doesn’t “wear out”.
3. Test UGC aimed at increasing AOV
A new hypothesis for further testing: “Combining several products in one video (e.g. handbag + wallet) will increase order value.”
If you’d like a similar A/B test or advice on adjusting your creative strategy, we’ll be happy to help.


