Influencer marketing has a reputation as either a miracle or money down the drain. We explain what an influencer is, how working with creators and UGC works, and how to tell whether a collaboration is making you money.
A company sends a parcel to a well-known face, it shows up once in a story, and then nothing happens. Or something happens, but nobody knows what, because nobody said up front what was supposed to happen. The problem is rarely the influencers. It's that the collaboration has no goal, no follow-up campaign and no way of being evaluated.
What is an influencer (and where the word comes from)
The word influencer comes from “influence”. An influencer is someone with an audience on social media, YouTube, a podcast or a blog that trusts them. And because that audience trusts them, they can shape what people buy, where they go or what they think about something.
It's not just celebrities with huge followings. A coach followed by a few thousand people for her workouts is an influencer, and so is a tradesman showing how things are done on YouTube. For a business, who follows them and how much they trust them matters more than how many there are.
- Celebrities and big creators. Huge reach, but a broad audience in which your customers are a minority. And a high price.
- Micro-influencers. Smaller, but a narrow and engaged audience in one field. They often deliver more than a celebrity.
- Experts in the field. A coach, a chef, an architect. Their recommendation carries weight because they know the subject.
- Your customers. People who talk about you on their own. The most credible of all, you just have to give them a reason.
How influencer marketing works
Influencer marketing is a collaboration in which a creator presents your product or service to their audience. It can be a single post, a video series, a review, a giveaway or a long-term ambassadorship. It works because of trust: a recommendation from someone you follow sounds different from an ad by a company.
That trust is fragile, though. An audience can tell when an influencer reads a script about a product they'd never use themselves. That's why the best collaborations are the ones where the creator, their audience and the product meet naturally, and where the creator can say it in their own words.
One post is not enough
The most common mistake is treating an influencer as a standalone stunt. A single post is gone in a day. A collaboration makes sense when it connects to the rest of your marketing: the creator's content keeps running in paid ads, people it caught see remarketing, and the website delivers what the creator promised. That's why influencer marketing belongs in the same plan as social media management, not in a drawer labelled “let's try it”.
UGC: content from customers and creators
UGC (user generated content) is content about a brand made by people outside the company: reviews, photos, unboxing videos, posts by happy customers. It works for the same reason influencers do. People trust other people more than they trust a company. Today the term covers two different things:
- Genuine customer content. A review with a photo, a post where someone tagged you. It happens on its own, but you can help it along: ask for a review after a purchase, give people a reason to show off, share their posts.
- Commissioned UGC videos. A creator shoots a video that looks like a customer's experience, and you use it in ads. They don't need an audience of their own; you pay for the content, not the reach.
Both can be used on your website, in emails and in ads. Always with the author's consent, and with paid content, without pretending it's a spontaneous review. The most common mistake? The content gets collected and then never used anywhere.
How to choose an influencer and tell whether it pays off
Choose an influencer by their audience, not their follower count: who follows them, whether the comments say anything, and who they've worked with before. You can tell a collaboration pays off from sales through a dedicated discount code and UTM link for each creator. Awareness can't be measured directly, so watch whether more people search for your brand.
Before you sign anything, look at:
- Who follows them. Age, country, interests. Influencers can show their audience breakdown from their stats, so ask for it.
- Real engagement. Comments that say something, not just hearts. Suspiciously fast follower growth or robotic comments can mean a bought audience.
- Who they've worked with before. If they're recommending three competing brands at once, their audience won't believe them.
- Whether they'd use the product without being paid. The best collaborations are the ones where the recommendation is true.
Decide up front what you want from the collaboration and how you'll know you got it. Sales can be measured with a discount code and UTM links for each creator. Awareness and trust can't be measured directly, but you can watch whether more people are searching for your brand. Settle the rights to the content in the contract so you can keep using it in ads. And paid collaborations must be clearly labelled as advertising. EU consumer law treats paid promotion that is not identifiable as such as an unfair practice, and Meta has its own branded content policies.
Example: A cosmetics e-shop can give its budget to one well-known face, or split it between several smaller creators in the field, each with their own discount code. A month later it knows which code brought in orders, and puts the best videos to work in social ads.
How many creators to work with, for how much and what to expect from them is something we decide on the Boost stair. There, influencer marketing has the same role in the media mix as every other channel: a clear job and numbers that tell us it's doing it.